Skip to main content

On how British news media might move on from framing the opt-out system as a silver bullet to the crisis of organ shortages

Mainstream news coverage of organ donation in the UK tends to emphasise the cases of families calling for the implementation of opt-out systems as a solution to the well-known problem of organ shortages and the long waiting lists endured by people with organ failure.

A recurrent frame in the coverage involves children and their parents campaigning for presumed consent laws to be enacted by politicians.

Well-known cases are captured in documentaries such as BBC Two's Heart Transplant: A Chance to Live, which was broadcast in May 2018 as the "Max Johnson and Keira Ball Law". This case had received significant levels of public attention, underpinned by The Mirror's campaign to change organ donation law in England. 

Broadcaster ITV has also been a fundamental provider of news content that promotes the opt-out system, visible in cases such as little Dáithí MacGabhann and Georgia Kirchin, to mention a few. 

Understandably, the families involved tend to express high hopes that an offspring's wait for an organ will end sooner when the opt-out framework is in place.

Frequently, such stories involve politicians playing with children who suffer organ failure, and policymakers supporting the premise that changing the law will result in better organ donation outcomes.

It would seem that media coverage of the opt-out system in places like Wales, Northern Ireland and England plays a significant role in promoting faith in the idea of such a policy as an antidote to the organ shortage crisis. 

Unrealistic expectations?

The news media role in promoting presumed consent resonates with findings in the Netherlands suggesting that unambiguous solutions of policy discourse in that country about organ shortages might result in unrealistic expectations, relative to clinical practices and experiences.

In Wales, increase in donation after brain death and circulatory death following implementation of presumed consent in December 2015 may have contributed to a favourable public discourse in England towards the policy. 

However, recent evidence from large scale comparisons across countries is that nations with opt-out systems have fewer living donors and similar rates of deceased donation, resonating with a trend that had already been identified nearly two decades ago. 

And as researchers claim, even successful experiences like that in Wales are relative and call for continued efforts to effect sustained improvement of donor behaviour over the long term. 

Moving beyond the opting-out system as a silver bullet frame

British news media adoption of presumed consent as a regular framing device of organ malfunction has its benefits in that it contributes to articulate the challenges of organ shortages in a way that is informative. 

As in the case of Max Johnson, such frame is frequently accompanied by reflections on the contribution of transplant science to improving the quality of life and the lifespan of people who suffer from organ failure. It is also potentially an antidote against the role of fictional misinformation in countering the benefits of expensive education campaigns that aim to improve organ donation and transplantation outcomes.

However, if the news media in Britain are to continue their tradition of campaigning journalism in Britain, there is a case to move beyond the frame of opting-out systems as an unambiguous solution to organ shortages. In a future post I will explore public discourse alternatives to do so.



 




Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Overcoming Media Reluctance: How a Diverse Messaging Strategy Can Boost Vaccination Advocacy

As the UK grapples with the resurgence of whooping cough, it becomes increasingly important for public health messaging to adopt a nuanced and multi-strategy approach to vaccination appeals. In recent weeks, the UK has witnessed a notable surge in whooping cough cases, a severe infection particularly dangerous to children and pregnant women. Public health messaging has strongly emphasized vaccination as a crucial measure to combat this infection. Naturally, this is the case in the official communication of the UK Health Security Agency. BBC's coverage highlights worrying rise of cases However, a quick examination of the mainstream media coverage reveals what could be described as a hesitancy to include direct vaccination appeals, as can be surmised from a BBC’s report  which emphasized the threatening aspect, and a local news report which highlighted its regional spread . While mentioning a decline in vaccination rates, the coverage avoided direct calls to vaccinate and mere...
Post a Comment
Read more

When a man is so bad he doesn't deserve a pig's heart

(Gabriel Moreno) - In words of The Washington Post writers , David Bennett became 'a medical pioneer' after the heart of a genetically modified pig was used to replace his failing heart. But the significance of this medical breakthrough in which he had been involved was eclipsed by the fact he 'had been convicted in 1988' after stabbing a man seven times. Attention grabbing as Johnson and Wan's article is, the so called 'ethics of a second chance' angle it deploys belongs within a category of public discourse that has taxed the ability of societies to deal with the organ shortage crisis  all over the world. For several decades, medical and social scientists have known that news media are one of the most effective forms of public education interventions to reduce the shortage of organs for patients who need a transplant for a shot at carrying on with their lives.  As put by Rafael Matesanz , architect of Spain's renowned national system of transplantation...
Post a Comment
Read more

Organ transplants: why so many people are put off donating

Organ transplants: why so many people are put off donating irinabdw/Shutterstock (I'm republishing this article from The Conversation partly as an opportunity to acknowledge the progress that the UK has made towards reducing the number of cases in which families refuse to donate the organs of loved ones after they die. With the consent/authorisation rate going up 2% in 2018/19 to 67%, the country is much closer to the 80% target that would dramatically improve transplant outcomes, per the latest   Organ Donation and Transplantation Activity Report . But there is more work to be done) Gabriel Moreno Esparza , Northumbria University, Newcastle and Stephen Clark , Northumbria University, Newcastle It’s well known that there’s a worldwide shortage of organ donors. More than 100,000 organ transplants have taken place around the world every year since 2008 but this is way below what’s needed . In the UK , for example, fi...
Post a Comment
Read more