As attempt of illegal organ procurement case to the UK picks up speed, those covering it should avoid using the sensationalist playbook

Those covering court proceedings involving an alleged case of illegal organ procurement to the UK should in my view highlight the strength of the organ allocation framework in the country.

Attention to the case has begun to gather speed in the last 24 or so hours and everyone involved in reporting it would do well to exercise caution in how they go about doing this.

As documented by experts (here's another example), this is the kind of extraordinary developments that feed into popular narratives that harm public confidence in reliable, well-established organ allocation systems.

Indeed, NHS Blood and Transplant provides transparent information about Organ donation laws with crystal clear explanation of how the system works in the United Kingdom.

And thus, that the people involved failed to persuade medics (paragraph four) to carry out the procedure could be emphasised instead of giving in to the temptation of sensationalist angles about illegality, plots, bribes, etc., one can find in the coverage - even that of news outlets known to adhere to strong journalistic ethics.

Court proceedings guarantee renewed attention to
the case, as illustrated by this recent BBC report)

When the story was first covered by The Daily Mail online, the reporter highlighted that a London doctor had rejected the procedure, but use of the expression "organ-harvesting parents", which paraphrased a prosecutors' statements, suggests the coverage stemmed from the sensationalist playbook.

None of this is to say that the events the press has been reporting are not worth reporting, since any transgressions to the legal framework need to be investigated and acted upon according to due process.

Responsible treatment of the subject, which absence is known to cause harm to a healthy culture of organ donation, is also essential.

As I've written before, transformation of public discourse about organ donation, including that contributed by the news media, has been going in the right direction in recent times.

But recent gains could be easily reversed and, as research suggests, the mediatisation of public health is subject to political and cultural forces that are sometimes uncontrollable (see here for an example). I'll aim to elaborate on this point in my next post.

Comments

Overcoming Media Reluctance: How a Diverse Messaging Strategy Can Boost Vaccination Advocacy

As the UK grapples with the resurgence of whooping cough, it becomes increasingly important for public health messaging to adopt a nuanced and multi-strategy approach to vaccination appeals. In recent weeks, the UK has witnessed a notable surge in whooping cough cases, a severe infection particularly dangerous to children and pregnant women. Public health messaging has strongly emphasized vaccination as a crucial measure to combat this infection. Naturally, this is the case in the official communication of the UK Health Security Agency. BBC's coverage highlights worrying rise of cases However, a quick examination of the mainstream media coverage reveals what could be described as a hesitancy to include direct vaccination appeals, as can be surmised from a BBC’s report which emphasized the threatening aspect, and a local news report which highlighted its regional spread . While mentioning a decline in vaccination rates, the coverage avoided direct calls to vaccinate and mere...

Organ transplants: why so many people are put off donating

Organ transplants: why so many people are put off donating irinabdw/Shutterstock (I'm republishing this article from The Conversation partly as an opportunity to acknowledge the progress that the UK has made towards reducing the number of cases in which families refuse to donate the organs of loved ones after they die. With the consent/authorisation rate going up 2% in 2018/19 to 67%, the country is much closer to the 80% target that would dramatically improve transplant outcomes, per the latest Organ Donation and Transplantation Activity Report . But there is more work to be done) Gabriel Moreno Esparza , Northumbria University, Newcastle and Stephen Clark , Northumbria University, Newcastle It’s well known that there’s a worldwide shortage of organ donors. More than 100,000 organ transplants have taken place around the world every year since 2008 but this is way below what’s needed . In the UK , for example, fi...

Rethinking Blood Donation: The Economics, Messaging, and Challenges

Blood transfusion is a critical medical procedure, yet the approach to securing a safe and sufficient blood supply involves complex economic, communicative, and logistical challenges which are difficult to understand when the messaging around it is haunted by catastrophic precedent such as the one that destroyed the lives of thousands in the UK in the 1970s and 1980s. Reflecting on these aspects reveals the importance of treating blood as a public good , rather than a commodity, central to preventing future crises like the one the news media will abundantly be reflecting when findings from the Infected Blood Inquiry are finally published. The Power of Messaging in Blood Donation Campaigns Effective communication in blood donation campaigns is crucial to ensuring a stable blood supply. Research indicates that the nature of these messages significantly influences public perception and willingness to donate. Traditional slogans like "Save Lives" are common, but recent studies ...

Communicating health

Search This Blog